I will update when I hear back from the doctor.
Finally heard back:
He wants us to go back on Clomid. Have one ultrasound around CD13 to confirm that I have follicles (eggs) forming. Then he wants me to get a HCG trigger shot to signal ovulation (overriding my own ovulation). Then we do one IUI on CD14 and one on CD15. Then back on progesterone after ovulation and re-check levels at 7 days post-ovulation to confirm proper progesterone rise. Holy smokes that is a lot of stuff. I am going to have to talk all this over with Brandon. $1500 later.....